{"status":"active","package_uuid":"b3f42269-4cae-41ab-893f-5604f1b993c8","package_hash":"sha256:7c6910e2ab7a00edc47a0dfbd6c0d692613a9d92edbc7bd2f24eea531c3721c5","hedera":{"topic_id":"0.0.1068","sequence_number":7878,"consensus_timestamp":"","transaction_id":"0.0.2@1791702660.901809814","message_hash":"sha256:2d5d358439ce4de6779a0953ae60a2029c7906653ec6ab198602b1c0e470255a","message":{"canonical_url":"https:\/\/pond.canuckduck.ca\/node\/34584","content_ref":"pond:node:34584:revision:42757","created_at":"2026-10-11T07:11:07+00:00","event_type":"TOPIC_PACKAGE_CERTIFIED","package_hash":"sha256:7c6910e2ab7a00edc47a0dfbd6c0d692613a9d92edbc7bd2f24eea531c3721c5","package_uuid":"b3f42269-4cae-41ab-893f-5604f1b993c8","registry_ref":"cdk-provenance-package:b3f42269-4cae-41ab-893f-5604f1b993c8","schema_version":"cdk.hedera.provenance.v1"}},"package_hash_valid":true,"package":{"attribution":{"attribution_hash":"sha256:35e8b0aae6c9bbc486ce6ed2c6a546a51994261d1c0462628c5d13116682e0a5","attribution_required":true,"canonical_backlink_required":true,"default_required_attribution_text":"Source: CanuckDUCK Pond \u2014 [FLOCK DEBATE] Limited Accountability in 4-Year Political Term \u2014 https:\/\/pond.canuckduck.ca\/node\/34584","default_required_attribution_text_hash":"sha256:9f0c33ec793908cc6a75d161825b3eb83b3d65676610c943bd78a18f431cd81c","license_profile":"cdk-public-attribution-v1","owner":"Canuckduck Research Corp","schema_version":"cdk.attribution.v1","status":"active","third_party_certificates":[{"canonical_backlink_required":true,"canonical_content_hash":"sha256:6087067330e316ed9d0c7a24dfa3dc901e97aa5ba2dfa85e3840b8cd9f34dbd2","canonical_url":"https:\/\/pond.canuckduck.ca\/node\/34584","certificate_hash":"sha256:45cd9477f8a65a723f8d734aa4b84e227ad1ba22c43bd7f903373c16811d1049","certificate_id":"cdk-attribution:b3f42269-4cae-41ab-893f-5604f1b993c8","certificate_type":"public_attribution_reuse","content_ref":"pond:node:34584:revision:42757","expires_at":null,"issued_at":"2026-10-11T07:11:07+00:00","issuer":"Canuckduck Research Corp","license_profile":"cdk-public-attribution-v1","not_permitted_by_this_certificate":["full_republication_without_separate_permission","misleading_context_or_false_affiliation","removal_of_required_attribution","use_of_private_or_nonpublic_material"],"package_uuid":"b3f42269-4cae-41ab-893f-5604f1b993c8","permitted_use_modes":["link","short_quote","summary","embed_verification_badge"],"privacy_note":"Certificate binds public content and attribution terms only; it does not expose private users, votes, or submissions.","required_attribution_text":"Source: CanuckDUCK Pond \u2014 [FLOCK DEBATE] Limited Accountability in 4-Year Political Term \u2014 https:\/\/pond.canuckduck.ca\/node\/34584","required_attribution_text_hash":"sha256:9f0c33ec793908cc6a75d161825b3eb83b3d65676610c943bd78a18f431cd81c","revocation_status":"not_revoked","rights_holder":"Canuckduck Research Corp","schema_version":"cdk.attribution_certificate.v1","status":"active","verification_url":"https:\/\/pond.canuckduck.ca\/node\/34584#cdk-provenance-package"}]},"consensus_binding":{"aggregate_manifest":{"aggregate_result_hash":null,"anonymized_data_ref":null,"public_data_status":"not_available","public_result_refs":[],"status":"not_available_without_poll_link"},"consensus_binding_hash":"sha256:6a186db88342f5da5b5e0308b0f999045c62e9f49da97f53d6ee8e6726b1bade","consensus_refs":[],"consensus_system":"consensus-webform","privacy_profile":"aggregate-public-v1","question_options_hash":"sha256:4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945","relationship_type":"unlinked_topic","schema_version":"cdk.consensus_binding.v1","small_cell_suppression":{"enabled":true,"minimum_group_size":5,"public_data_status":"not_available"},"source":{"field_consensus_poll_id_present":true,"pond_node_id":34584,"processed_comment_links":[]},"status":"no_consensus_link_found"},"content_certificate":{"canonical_content_hash":"sha256:6087067330e316ed9d0c7a24dfa3dc901e97aa5ba2dfa85e3840b8cd9f34dbd2","canonical_payload_hash_basis":"cdk.content_canonical.v1","canonical_url":"https:\/\/pond.canuckduck.ca\/node\/34584","content_ref":{"bundle":"forum","entity_id":34584,"entity_type":"node","revision_id":42757,"system":"pond"}},"created_at":"2026-10-11T07:11:06+00:00","geo_scope":{"canonical_paths":["\/ca","\/ca\/ab","\/ca\/bc","\/ca\/mb","\/ca\/nb","\/ca\/nl","\/ca\/ns","\/ca\/nt","\/ca\/nu","\/ca\/on","\/ca\/pe","\/ca\/qc","\/ca\/sk","\/ca\/yt"],"geo_hash":"sha256:624dc90365ae56769351b80629ec1b9cf3960ccff674f8752df804902b86901d","geo_manifest_ref":"cdk-provenance:geo-scope:pond:node:34584","jurisdictions":[{"canonical_path":"\/ca","code":"CA","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","name":"Canada","scope_type":"national","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/ab","code":"CA-AB","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:1","name":"Alberta","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Alberta","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/bc","code":"CA-BC","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:13","name":"British Columbia","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ British Columbia","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/mb","code":"CA-MB","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:11","name":"Manitoba","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Manitoba","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/nb","code":"CA-NB","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:5","name":"New Brunswick","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ New Brunswick","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/nl","code":"CA-NL","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:6","name":"Newfoundland and Labrador","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Newfoundland and Labrador","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/ns","code":"CA-NS","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:9","name":"Nova Scotia","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Nova Scotia","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/nt","code":"CA-NT","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:8","name":"Northwest Territories","scope_type":"territorial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Northwest Territories","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/nu","code":"CA-NU","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2","name":"Nunavut","scope_type":"territorial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Nunavut","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/on","code":"CA-ON","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:10","name":"Ontario","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Ontario","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/pe","code":"CA-PE","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:7","name":"Prince Edward Island","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Prince Edward Island","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/qc","code":"CA-QC","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:4","name":"Quebec","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Quebec","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/sk","code":"CA-SK","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:3","name":"Saskatchewan","scope_type":"provincial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Saskatchewan","vocabulary":"geography"},{"canonical_path":"\/ca\/yt","code":"CA-YT","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:12","name":"Yukon","scope_type":"territorial","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Yukon","vocabulary":"geography"}],"schema_version":"cdk.geo_scope.v1","scope_type":"national","source":{"basis":"canonical_url_and_pond_taxonomy","content_ref":"pond:node:34584"},"status":"metadata_enriched"},"graph_pathway_certificate":{"counts":{"jurisdictions":14,"related_articles":1,"relationships":30,"sources":6,"variables":36},"graph_pathway_hash":"sha256:aeae32b06374b6ba32d835fed2a13c364186ad7abc0ed045cb44f1f823ba5f2d","graph_snapshot_id":"pond-ripple-relationships:count-4025:updated-1770230740","graph_system":"pond-ripple-extraction+ripple-api","manifest":{"content_ref":"pond:node:34584","jurisdictions":[{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:1","name":"Alberta","path":"Canada \/ Alberta","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:10","name":"Ontario","path":"Canada \/ Ontario","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:11","name":"Manitoba","path":"Canada \/ Manitoba","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:12","name":"Yukon","path":"Canada \/ Yukon","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:13","name":"British Columbia","path":"Canada \/ British Columbia","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2","name":"Nunavut","path":"Canada \/ Nunavut","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","name":"Canada","path":"Canada","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:3","name":"Saskatchewan","path":"Canada \/ Saskatchewan","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:4","name":"Quebec","path":"Canada \/ Quebec","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:5","name":"New Brunswick","path":"Canada \/ New Brunswick","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:6","name":"Newfoundland and Labrador","path":"Canada \/ Newfoundland and Labrador","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:7","name":"Prince Edward Island","path":"Canada \/ Prince Edward Island","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:8","name":"Northwest Territories","path":"Canada \/ Northwest Territories","source":"pond-taxonomy"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:9","name":"Nova Scotia","path":"Canada \/ Nova Scotia","source":"pond-taxonomy"}],"query_profile":"pond-ripple-term-api-context-v1","relationships":[{"confidence":0.934,"evidence_type":"none","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:533","source_comment_count":2,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"civic engagement","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.624,"evidence_type":"none","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:539","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"community safety","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.624,"evidence_type":"none","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:540","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"justice system","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.589,"evidence_type":"none","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:538","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.589,"evidence_type":"statistical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:531","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"economic_development","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.589,"evidence_type":"statistical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:530","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"housing","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.589,"evidence_type":"statistical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:532","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"municipal_finance","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.589,"evidence_type":"none","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:537","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"transportation","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.575,"evidence_type":"statistical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:541","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"civic_engagement","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.575,"evidence_type":"statistical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:543","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"housing_and_property_taxes","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.575,"evidence_type":"statistical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:544","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"local_governance","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.575,"evidence_type":"statistical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:542","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"voter_participation","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.555,"evidence_type":"theoretical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:535","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"employment","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.555,"evidence_type":"theoretical","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:536","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"public_safety","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0},{"confidence":0.555,"evidence_type":"none","relationship_id":"pond-ripple-relationship:534","source_comment_count":1,"source_term_id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","source_term_path":"civic_engagement_and_voter_participation\/the_4_year_political_cycle_problem\/4_years_of_power_0_years_of_recourse","target_domain":"voter participation","updated":1770230740,"vote_score":0}],"ripple_api_context":{"api_base_ref":"http:\/\/10.0.1.75:8090\/api\/v2","relationships":[{"confidence":0.8,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:downstream:alberta_gdp:alberta_corporate_income_tax","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Alberta Nominal GDP","source_var_id":"alberta_gdp","strength":0.015,"target_label":"Alberta Corporate Income Tax","target_var_id":"alberta_corporate_income_tax"},{"confidence":0.85,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:downstream:alberta_gdp:alberta_personal_income_tax","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Alberta Nominal GDP","source_var_id":"alberta_gdp","strength":1,"target_label":"Alberta Personal Income Tax","target_var_id":"alberta_personal_income_tax"},{"confidence":0.7,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:downstream:alberta_gdp:calgary_property_tax","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Alberta Nominal GDP","source_var_id":"alberta_gdp","strength":0.3,"target_label":"Calgary Property Tax","target_var_id":"calgary_property_tax"},{"confidence":1,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:downstream:alberta_resource_revenue:alberta_revenues","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Alberta Resource Revenue","source_var_id":"alberta_resource_revenue","strength":0.285,"target_label":"Alberta Total Revenues","target_var_id":"alberta_revenues"},{"confidence":0.65,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:downstream:cybersecurity_workforce_gap:critical_infrastructure_cyber_exposure","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Cybersecurity Workforce Gap","source_var_id":"cybersecurity_workforce_gap","strength":0.45,"target_label":"Critical Infrastructure Cyber Exposure Index","target_var_id":"critical_infrastructure_cyber_exposure"},{"confidence":0.7,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:downstream:cybersecurity_workforce_gap:cyber_breaches_reported_annual","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Cybersecurity Workforce Gap","source_var_id":"cybersecurity_workforce_gap","strength":0.4,"target_label":"Reported Cyber Breaches Annual","target_var_id":"cyber_breaches_reported_annual"},{"confidence":0.55,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:downstream:cybersecurity_workforce_gap:cyber_incident_cost_annual","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Cybersecurity Workforce Gap","source_var_id":"cybersecurity_workforce_gap","strength":0.45,"target_label":"Cyber Incident Cost (Annual, All Sectors)","target_var_id":"cyber_incident_cost_annual"},{"confidence":0.8,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:alberta_gdp:calgary_stampede_economic_impact","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Calgary Stampede Economic Impact (Alberta)","source_var_id":"calgary_stampede_economic_impact","strength":0.2,"target_label":"Alberta Nominal GDP","target_var_id":"alberta_gdp"},{"confidence":0.8,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:alberta_gdp:energy_exports_to_us","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Energy Exports to US","source_var_id":"energy_exports_to_us","strength":0.3,"target_label":"Alberta Nominal GDP","target_var_id":"alberta_gdp"},{"confidence":0.88,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:alberta_gdp:oil_price_wti","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"WTI Oil Price","source_var_id":"oil_price_wti","strength":0.45,"target_label":"Alberta Nominal GDP","target_var_id":"alberta_gdp"},{"confidence":1,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:alberta_resource_revenue:alberta_bitumen_royalties","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Alberta Bitumen Royalties","source_var_id":"alberta_bitumen_royalties","strength":0.694,"target_label":"Alberta Resource Revenue","target_var_id":"alberta_resource_revenue"},{"confidence":0.85,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:alberta_resource_revenue:alberta_oil_export_volume","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Alberta Oil Export Volume","source_var_id":"alberta_oil_export_volume","strength":0.8,"target_label":"Alberta Resource Revenue","target_var_id":"alberta_resource_revenue"},{"confidence":0.85,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:alberta_resource_revenue:oil_export_volume","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Oil Export Volume","source_var_id":"oil_export_volume","strength":0.6,"target_label":"Alberta Resource Revenue","target_var_id":"alberta_resource_revenue"},{"confidence":0.45,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:cybersecurity_workforce_gap:housing_affordability","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"Housing Affordability Index","source_var_id":"housing_affordability","strength":0.65,"target_label":"Cybersecurity Workforce Gap","target_var_id":"cybersecurity_workforce_gap"},{"confidence":0.7,"direction":"positive","relationship_id":"ripple-api:upstream:cybersecurity_workforce_gap:stem_graduation_rate","source":"ripple-api","source_label":"STEM Graduation Rate","source_var_id":"stem_graduation_rate","strength":0.3,"target_label":"Cybersecurity Workforce Gap","target_var_id":"cybersecurity_workforce_gap"}],"search_queries":["4 Years of Power, 0 Years of Recourse","AI-generated","Alberta","British Columbia","Canada","Civic Engagement and Voter Participation"],"status":"matched","variables":[{"category":"operational","description_hash":"sha256:1e0d8f082b02ae3e4a0ad571dbddc80309d2ceeedbba287fee9ec926312d516b","downstream_count":5,"label":"Cybersecurity Workforce Gap","matched_query":"AI-generated","relevance":18,"upstream_count":2,"var_id":"cybersecurity_workforce_gap"},{"category":"economic","description_hash":"sha256:998227934155fb2200335e017a9acf48e64207b547d867e9119513469c320f1e","downstream_count":3,"label":"Alberta Nominal GDP","matched_query":"Alberta","relevance":74,"upstream_count":8,"var_id":"alberta_gdp"},{"category":"fiscal","description_hash":"sha256:966979a18d606a395ed5ab6a1b6e107314c682dfb2b4d931b144a8039c5baaee","downstream_count":1,"label":"Alberta Resource Revenue","matched_query":"Alberta","relevance":74,"upstream_count":7,"var_id":"alberta_resource_revenue"},{"category":"fiscal","description_hash":"sha256:f9045bbc789c84ad1c5105364439f1097dd188f54a5316799bd4573f7bb66179","downstream_count":2,"label":"Alberta Total Revenues","matched_query":"Alberta","relevance":74,"upstream_count":6,"var_id":"alberta_revenues"},{"category":"economic","description_hash":null,"downstream_count":4,"label":"British Columbia Nominal GDP","matched_query":"British Columbia","relevance":70,"upstream_count":5,"var_id":"bc_gdp"},{"category":"fiscal","description_hash":"sha256:a09de22f3f74ddaf1a3416cb58efa5b0e568708094bd177dfd0add1ff881289c","downstream_count":1,"label":"British Columbia Budget Surplus","matched_query":"British Columbia","relevance":70,"upstream_count":2,"var_id":"bc_surplus"},{"category":"government_operations","description_hash":"sha256:f79c47bfc8316e33cf144e1c05ee99414ee1f6bdddb7e8814d3701d1c83a06f4","downstream_count":1,"label":"British Columbia Provincial Spending","matched_query":"British Columbia","relevance":70,"upstream_count":1,"var_id":"provincial_spending_bc"}]},"schema_version":"cdk.graph_pathway.v1","taxonomy_terms":[{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:1","name":"Alberta","path":"Canada \/ Alberta","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:10","name":"Ontario","path":"Canada \/ Ontario","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:11","name":"Manitoba","path":"Canada \/ Manitoba","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:12","name":"Yukon","path":"Canada \/ Yukon","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:13","name":"British Columbia","path":"Canada \/ British Columbia","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2","name":"Nunavut","path":"Canada \/ Nunavut","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","name":"Canada","path":"Canada","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","name":"4 Years of Power, 0 Years of Recourse","path":"Civic Engagement and Voter Participation \/ The 4-Year Political Cycle Problem \/ 4 Years of Power, 0 Years of Recourse","vocabulary":"national_forum_topics"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:3","name":"Saskatchewan","path":"Canada \/ Saskatchewan","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34574","name":"Governance and democratic institutions","path":"Governance and democratic institutions","vocabulary":"cdk_civic_domain"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34616","name":"Pond Flock Debate","path":"Pond Flock Debate","vocabulary":"cdk_artifact_type"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34634","name":"Published","path":"Published","vocabulary":"cdk_lifecycle_status"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34644","name":"AI-generated","path":"AI-generated","vocabulary":"cdk_provenance"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34660","name":"Public","path":"Public","vocabulary":"cdk_audience_lane"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34669","name":"Public","path":"Public","vocabulary":"cdk_sensitivity"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:4","name":"Quebec","path":"Canada \/ Quebec","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:5","name":"New Brunswick","path":"Canada \/ New Brunswick","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:6","name":"Newfoundland and Labrador","path":"Canada \/ Newfoundland and Labrador","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:7","name":"Prince Edward Island","path":"Canada \/ Prince Edward Island","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:8","name":"Northwest Territories","path":"Canada \/ Northwest Territories","vocabulary":"geography"},{"id":"pond:taxonomy_term:9","name":"Nova Scotia","path":"Canada \/ Nova Scotia","vocabulary":"geography"}]},"pathway_manifest_hash":"sha256:4c7dcbf9064587a3d548b50889c4ec1acea34449911faa5431493ac914dc4182","pathway_manifest_ref":"cdk-provenance:graph-pathway:pond:node:34584:sha256:4c7dcbf9064587a3d548b50889c4ec1acea34449911faa5431493ac914dc4182","query_profile":"pond-ripple-term-api-context-v1","schema_version":"cdk.graph_pathway.v1","status":"manifested","touched":{"article_ids":["pond:node:34584"],"jurisdiction_ids":["pond:taxonomy_term:1","pond:taxonomy_term:10","pond:taxonomy_term:11","pond:taxonomy_term:12","pond:taxonomy_term:13","pond:taxonomy_term:2","pond:taxonomy_term:2549","pond:taxonomy_term:3","pond:taxonomy_term:4","pond:taxonomy_term:5","pond:taxonomy_term:6","pond:taxonomy_term:7","pond:taxonomy_term:8","pond:taxonomy_term:9"],"relationship_ids":["pond-ripple-relationship:533","pond-ripple-relationship:539","pond-ripple-relationship:540","pond-ripple-relationship:538","pond-ripple-relationship:531","pond-ripple-relationship:530","pond-ripple-relationship:532","pond-ripple-relationship:537","pond-ripple-relationship:541","pond-ripple-relationship:543","pond-ripple-relationship:544","pond-ripple-relationship:542","pond-ripple-relationship:535","pond-ripple-relationship:536","pond-ripple-relationship:534"],"source_ids":["pond:comment:3275","pond:comment:3505","pond:comment:3519","pond:comment:4365","pond:comment:5935","pond:comment:8969"],"variable_ids":["ripple-domain:civic engagement","ripple-domain:civic_engagement","ripple-domain:civic_engagement_and_voter_participation","ripple-domain:community safety","ripple-domain:economic_development","ripple-domain:employment","ripple-domain:housing","ripple-domain:housing_and_property_taxes","ripple-domain:justice system","ripple-domain:local_governance","ripple-domain:municipal_finance","ripple-domain:public_safety","ripple-domain:transportation","ripple-domain:voter participation","ripple-domain:voter_participation","ripple-variable:alberta_bitumen_royalties","ripple-variable:alberta_corporate_income_tax","ripple-variable:alberta_gdp","ripple-variable:alberta_oil_export_volume","ripple-variable:alberta_personal_income_tax","ripple-variable:alberta_resource_revenue","ripple-variable:alberta_revenues","ripple-variable:bc_gdp","ripple-variable:bc_surplus","ripple-variable:calgary_property_tax","ripple-variable:calgary_stampede_economic_impact","ripple-variable:critical_infrastructure_cyber_exposure","ripple-variable:cyber_breaches_reported_annual","ripple-variable:cyber_incident_cost_annual","ripple-variable:cybersecurity_workforce_gap","ripple-variable:energy_exports_to_us","ripple-variable:housing_affordability","ripple-variable:oil_export_volume","ripple-variable:oil_price_wti","ripple-variable:provincial_spending_bc","ripple-variable:stem_graduation_rate"]}},"package_hash":"sha256:7c6910e2ab7a00edc47a0dfbd6c0d692613a9d92edbc7bd2f24eea531c3721c5","package_type":"CDK_TOPIC_PROVENANCE_PACKAGE","package_uuid":"b3f42269-4cae-41ab-893f-5604f1b993c8","schema_version":"cdk.topic_provenance.v1","source_categorization_certificate":{"candidate_jurisdictions":[{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:10","label":"Ontario","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Ontario","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:11","label":"Manitoba","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Manitoba","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:12","label":"Yukon","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Yukon","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:13","label":"British Columbia","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ British Columbia","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:1","label":"Alberta","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Alberta","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","label":"Canada","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_cdk_geography","taxonomy_path":"Canada","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","label":"Canada","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2","label":"Nunavut","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Nunavut","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:3","label":"Saskatchewan","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Saskatchewan","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:4","label":"Quebec","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Quebec","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:5","label":"New Brunswick","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ New Brunswick","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:6","label":"Newfoundland and Labrador","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Newfoundland and Labrador","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:7","label":"Prince Edward Island","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Prince Edward Island","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:8","label":"Northwest Territories","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Northwest Territories","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:9","label":"Nova Scotia","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Nova Scotia","vocabulary":"geography"}],"candidate_ripple_variables":[],"candidate_topics":[{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","label":"4 Years of Power, 0 Years of Recourse","role":"topic_or_domain","source_field":"taxonomy_forums","taxonomy_path":"Civic Engagement and Voter Participation \/ The 4-Year Political Cycle Problem \/ 4 Years of Power, 0 Years of Recourse","vocabulary":"national_forum_topics"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34574","label":"Governance and democratic institutions","role":"topic_or_domain","source_field":"field_cdk_civic_domain","taxonomy_path":"Governance and democratic institutions","vocabulary":"cdk_civic_domain"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34616","label":"Pond Flock Debate","role":"topic_or_domain","source_field":"field_cdk_artifact_type","taxonomy_path":"Pond Flock Debate","vocabulary":"cdk_artifact_type"}],"civic_metadata":[{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","label":"Canada","role":"civic_metadata","source_field":"field_cdk_geography","taxonomy_path":"Canada","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34574","label":"Governance and democratic institutions","role":"civic_metadata","source_field":"field_cdk_civic_domain","taxonomy_path":"Governance and democratic institutions","vocabulary":"cdk_civic_domain"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34616","label":"Pond Flock Debate","role":"civic_metadata","source_field":"field_cdk_artifact_type","taxonomy_path":"Pond Flock Debate","vocabulary":"cdk_artifact_type"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34634","label":"Published","role":"civic_metadata","source_field":"field_cdk_lifecycle_status","taxonomy_path":"Published","vocabulary":"cdk_lifecycle_status"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34644","label":"AI-generated","role":"civic_metadata","source_field":"field_cdk_provenance","taxonomy_path":"AI-generated","vocabulary":"cdk_provenance"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34660","label":"Public","role":"civic_metadata","source_field":"field_cdk_audience_lane","taxonomy_path":"Public","vocabulary":"cdk_audience_lane"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34669","label":"Public","role":"civic_metadata","source_field":"field_cdk_sensitivity","taxonomy_path":"Public","vocabulary":"cdk_sensitivity"}],"classified_at":"2026-10-11T07:11:07+00:00","classifier_profile":"pond-drupal-taxonomy-current-state-v1","correction_intake":{"activation_rule":"corrections appear in public provenance only after admin approval","admin_review_intake":"admin may create a pending correction directly during review","support_ticket_intake":"support.canuckduck.ca ticket reference can be attached to a pending correction request"},"correction_policy":{"corrections_supersede_prior_decisions":true,"expected_misclassification":true,"public_reviewer_identity":"role_or_public_safe_ref_only"},"manual_corrections":[{"admin_approval_ref":"classifier:cdk.geo_classifier.v1","approved_at":"2026-10-11T06:40:56+00:00","correction_hash":"sha256:ffe688fa51e865da51520374719836f9749576435d687c91c5244960a8bf67d4","correction_id":"cdk-source-correction:73","correction_payload":{"classifier":"cdk.geo_classifier.v1","confidence":"high","dimension":"geo","focus":[],"from":{"provinces":[],"scope":"unknown","tids":[]},"reasons":["untagged; no place evidence; forum container national_forum_topics is national-level"],"to":{"provinces":[],"scope":"national","tids":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,2549]}},"reason_code":"geo_gap_fill","source_type":"classifier","status":"auto_applied","support_ticket_ref":null}],"manual_review_status":"corrected_classifier","privacy_note":"Includes public-safe taxonomy\/routing refs only; it does not expose private reviewer IDs, internal notes, raw graph dumps, or nonpublic source text.","routing_decision_hash":"sha256:3a861ab3d3a2ab1b51984d5189a1e22944a987c8afebc2293ce84a98ec9d147c","schema_version":"cdk.source_categorization.v1","selected_jurisdictions":[{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:10","label":"Ontario","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Ontario","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:11","label":"Manitoba","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Manitoba","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:12","label":"Yukon","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Yukon","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:13","label":"British Columbia","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ British Columbia","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:1","label":"Alberta","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Alberta","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","label":"Canada","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_cdk_geography","taxonomy_path":"Canada","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2549","label":"Canada","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:2","label":"Nunavut","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Nunavut","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:3","label":"Saskatchewan","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Saskatchewan","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:4","label":"Quebec","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Quebec","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:5","label":"New Brunswick","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ New Brunswick","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:6","label":"Newfoundland and Labrador","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Newfoundland and Labrador","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:7","label":"Prince Edward Island","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Prince Edward Island","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:8","label":"Northwest Territories","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Northwest Territories","vocabulary":"geography"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:9","label":"Nova Scotia","role":"jurisdiction","source_field":"field_province","taxonomy_path":"Canada \/ Nova Scotia","vocabulary":"geography"}],"selected_ripple_variables":[],"selected_topics":[{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:265","label":"4 Years of Power, 0 Years of Recourse","role":"topic_or_domain","source_field":"taxonomy_forums","taxonomy_path":"Civic Engagement and Voter Participation \/ The 4-Year Political Cycle Problem \/ 4 Years of Power, 0 Years of Recourse","vocabulary":"national_forum_topics"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34574","label":"Governance and democratic institutions","role":"topic_or_domain","source_field":"field_cdk_civic_domain","taxonomy_path":"Governance and democratic institutions","vocabulary":"cdk_civic_domain"},{"confidence_band":"existing_drupal_metadata","id":"pond:taxonomy_term:34616","label":"Pond Flock Debate","role":"topic_or_domain","source_field":"field_cdk_artifact_type","taxonomy_path":"Pond Flock Debate","vocabulary":"cdk_artifact_type"}],"source_categorization_hash":"sha256:04a2fe1ac74c8ea4d0809730c281ea4e51df226d8982d648b4d40a6e6f8b0ab2","source_hash":"sha256:6087067330e316ed9d0c7a24dfa3dc901e97aa5ba2dfa85e3840b8cd9f34dbd2","source_ref":"pond:node:34584:revision:42757","source_url":"https:\/\/pond.canuckduck.ca\/node\/34584","status":"active","taxonomy_basis_hash":"sha256:3e71d5c0c910cb3ceb1fd4b9f81197009fb69ef5f94fee09faa62562e1a4a7a2"}}}